Good Debt vs. Bad Debt in Entrepreneurship: A Small Business Owner’s Guide
Debt. The word alone might send a shiver down the spine of many small business owners. We’re often told to avoid debt like the plague, right? But in the world of entrepreurship, not all debt is created equal. In fact, some debt can be a powerful tool to fuel your business’s growth, while other debt can slowly sink the ship. Understanding the difference between good debt and bad debt is key to making smart financial decisions for your business. Let’s break it down in plain language, with a few examples (and even a bit of fun along the way).
What Is “Good” Debt?
Good debt is the kind that works for you, not against you. It’s money you borrow to invest in something that has strong potential to increase your business’s value or income over time. Think of it as debt that returns money to your pocket in the long run, rather than just taking it out. For example, taking out a loan to buy a piece of equipment that lets you produce more goods or serve more customers can be good debt. If the new machine or tools helps boost your revenue beyond the cost of the loan, that debt has effectively paid for itself and then some.
In short, good debt is strategic. It’s used to expand operations, improve efficiency, or capture new opportunities that lead to profits. It usually comes with reasonable terms (often lower interest rates and longer repayment periods), so it doesn’t strangle your cash flow. A classic mantra here is: borrow money so your can make money.
What is “Bad” Debt”
Bad debt, on the other hand, is the kind that drains your resources without boosting your business’s value. It’s money borrowed for things that don’t generate income or appreciate – in other words, debt that takes money out of your pocket, without bringing anything back in. Bad debt often comes with high interest rates, short repayment terms, or unforgiving conditions that make it hard to keep up.
Common culprits include running up credit card debt to cover routine expenses or splurges on nice-to-have items. Credit cards might be easy to use in a pinch, but they carry steep interest rates (often around 20% interest on balances) which means if you don’t pay them off quickly, that debt snowballs fast. Another prime example is payday loans or quick cash advances with sky-high fees. These short-term loans are infamous for their exorbitant interest rates and can trap businesses in a cycle of debt.
In general, any debt used to buy something that doesn’t help your business earn more, like a fancy new office couch you really can’t afford, or covering months of losses with no plan, can be considered bad debt. It offers no real pathway to increase your business’s value and just eats away at your cash.
Why the Difference Matters
Understanding good vs. bad debt isn’t just a theoretical exercise, it has real implications for your business’s health. Good debt can be a powerful lever for growth. It can help you seize opportunities now rather than waiting years to save up capital. Used wisely, it can alleviate strain on your cash flow and pay for itself through the extra income it generates. Taking on a reasonable loan and paying it off diligently can even improve your credit and make future financing easier (demonstrating to banks or investors that you can handle credit responsibly). Bad debt in contrast, can become a dangerous anchor. In the short term, too much debt means more of your monthly income is eaten be debt payments, leaving you scrambling to cover expenses or invest in growth. In the long run, piling up bad debt can hurt your credit rating and reputation, making it harder to get good loans when you really need it. Essentially good debt gives you a ladder to climb higher, whereas bad debt digs a hole that gets harder and harder to escape. As a business owner, you want to use debt as a tool to help build your enterprise, not as a crutch that props up a failing situation.
Before taking on any new debt, a handy rule of thumb is to ask yourself a few key question.
- Will this debt help my business earn more become more valuable?
- Can I realistically afford the payments even if things get a bit bumpy?
If the answer is “no”, you might be looking at bad debt. But if the debt is tied to a solid plan for growth, with manageable costs, it could be a beneficial move. As one Canadian expert put it, healthy debt entails borrowing money for things that do not depreciate and will bring a positive return in the future. In other words, debt should really be an investment, not an expense.
Good vs. Bad Debt in Different Industries
Every business is unique, and what counts as good or bad debt can depend on your industry and situation. Let’s explore a few theoretical scenarios across different industries to see how the concept plays out:
1. Retail or Restaurant Business
If you run a boutique or a cozy cafe, you might need to invest in inventory, storefront improvements, or kitchen equipment. Borrowing, say, $50,000 to renovate your space and add more seating could be good debt if it draws in more customers and increases revenue (imagine doubling your cafe’s capacity and seeing a proportional jump in sales). A loan for purchasing high-demand inventory ahead of a busy season is another example of debt that can pay off, because you’re using it to generate more sales.
On the flip side, taking on debt to cover operational losses with no plan for recovery can be trouble. For instance, using a high interest short-term loan to simply pay this month’s bills because sales are down is likely bad debt as it’s not fixing the underlying problem and comes with heavy costs. Also, splurging on non-essentials with debt is a trap: that $10,000 designer decor for the shop might look great, but if it doesn’t boost customer spending, it’s not worth the credit card debt incurred (especially at 20% interest on the card). In retail and food service, use debt for growth, not just to tread water.
2. Service-Based Business (e.g. consulting, trades, agencies)
Service businesses often have lower upfront capital needs, but they ight need an infusion of funds to scale up operations. Picture a small marketing agency or an HVAC repair company. A good debt move here could be financing the hiring of a new skilled employee or purchasing an additional work van. Yes, taking a loan to hire someone or buy a vehicle adds cost, but if it means you can serve more clients and increase profits, it’s a net win. Another example: investing in a training program or software tools that make your service more efficient; a reasonable line of credit could fund this and lead to higher earnings down the road.
In contrast, bad debt for a service business usually looks like overextending on credit for day-to-day expenses. For instance, a freelance consultant putting all their travel, gadgets, and fancy office furniture on a personal credit card without a clear return can end up drowning in debt without growing the business (those are “luxury” expenses that don’t bring income). Likewise, taking out a personal loan to cover a short-term cashflow gap can turn into bad debt if the business isn’t generating enough to repay it. The lesson for service businesses is to borrow with purpose; if it doesn’t help you serve more clients or improve your service, think twice.
3. Tech Startup or Online Business
Tech entrepreneurs often hear the mantra “grow fast”, and debt can sometimes help with that, but caution is key. A good debt example in a tech startup could be utilizing a business line of credit to finance cloud infrastructure or product development after you’ve landed some paying users. If a modest amount of debt helps you roll out a new feature faster or keep servers running, and that results in more users or revenue, it’s likely a smart use of debt. Some startups also use venture debt (a loan designed for startups) in conjunction with investor funds to accelerate growth; this can be good debt if it extends your runway to hit critical milestones.
However, tech and online businesses are notorious for burning cash, so bad debt is a real risk. Taking on a large loan before you have a proven revenue stream can be disastrous – for example, borrowing heavily to rent a swanky office and deck it out with expensive furniture (ping-pong tables included) doesn’t generate income and could leave you in a hole if profits don’t materialize. Similarly, maxing credit cards lines to finance user acquisition without tracking ROI is dangerous. In the fast-paced tech world, debt must be tied to a clear growth strategy. If it’s just funding a “fake it till you make it” spending spree, that’s bad debt territory.
4. Manufacturing or Trades (Construction, etc.)
In industries like manufacturing, construction, or any trade that requires heavy equipment, debt is often a part of doing business as equipment and machinery are costly. Good debt in this context might be a loan to purchase a new piece of equipment that significantly increases production capacity or efficiency. For example, a small furniture manufacturer might finance a new cutting machine that doubles output; if demand is there, the increased sales can more than cover the loan payments. Likewise, a construction contractor might take on debt to buy an additional truck or specialized tool, enabling them to take on more jobs at once – that’s using debt to grow the top line. These types of assets tend to hold value for some time, which makes the debt less risky.
Bad debt in manufacturing or trades often comes from taking short term, high cost loans to cover misaligned cash flow. Let’s say a contractor underestimates project costs and runs short on cash for payroll – resorting to a quick cash advance (with say, a 30% interest rate) would be an expensive patch. If that debt isn’t directly tied to generating more revenue (and if this case it’s just covering an error), it can cut deeply into future earnings. Another red flag would be financing things that depreciate too quickly: buying a luxury company car on credit, for instance, when a basic vehicle would do, is generally bad debt for a small business (you’re paying interest on an asset that loses value and doesn’t improve your output). In asset-heavy industries, focus debt on assets that earn money, not just those that look impressive.
——————————-
To make the difference between good debt a little clearer, let’s look at a fictional business owner navigating real financial choices. The following case study paints a practical picture of how smart borrowing can fuel growth and how the wrong kind of debt can create unnecessary strain
Final Thoughts!
As a small business owner, the goal isn’t to avoid debt at all costs, it’s to embrace the right kind of debt and steer clear of the wrong kind. Good debt can by your ally, a tool that provides a ladder for your business to climb to the next level. Bad debt, however, is more like quicksand that can pull you down if you’re not careful. The difference comes down to intent and impact: Are you borrowing for something that will likely pay off and strengthen your business? Or are are you borrowing just to plug holes or buy things that don’t generate value?
Keep the conversation about debt open and honest with yourself and your team. Evaluate each opportunity: run the numbers, consider the best-and-worse scenarios, and have a repayment plan. If interest rates seem high, remember that in many cases business loan interest is tax-deductible, which can soften the blow (interest can sometimes even work in your favour with the right tax strategy). Still, you never want to rely on deductions to justify a bad deal – the debt should stand on its own merit as a positive investment in your company’s future.
In Canada (and many other places), there are resources to help entrepreneurs access good debt on reasonable terms, from government backed small business financing programs to community development loans. These options often offer lower rates, longer terms, or mentoring support – all ingredients of debt that helps rather than hurts. By contrast, predatory lenders and ultra-high interest products are the natural enemies of a healthy small business budget.
In the end, debt is a tool – like a hammer, it can build something great, or cause a lot of damage if used recklessly. The next time you face a financing decision, take a step back and determine: Is this debt going to earn its keep by boosting my business, or will it just drain our funds? Keep it simple: if it’s likely to put money back into your business’s pockets, it’ probably good debt; if it’s only going to take money out of your pocket, consider it bad debt and think twice.
By leaning into good debt and avoiding the bad, you’ll position your business to grow, thrive, and navigate the financial challenges of entrepreneurship with confidence. After all, the goal is not just to build a business, but to build one that’s financially sustainable – and knowing your good debt from your bad debt is a savvy step in that direction. Here’s to making debt work for you, and not the other way around!
References
- Bluevine (2023). Good debt vs. bad debt for businesses.
- US Chamber of Commerce (2021). What is Good Debt and Bad Debt for a Small Business?
- Women’s Enterprise Organization of Canada (2024). How good debt can fuel your business growth.
- MNP Ltd. (2024). Decoding Debt: The difference between good and bad.
